Tuesday, August 18, 2009

Brands Are Moving Away From Coupons and Toward CRM

CM Comment: Interesting perspective on coupons. Article offers that coupons cannot be used to drive repeat purchase over time, but rather are designed to spur trial among non-users.

August 10, 2009: summarized from AdAge.com -- Advertisers from Domino's Pizza to Victoria's Secret have begun building out mobile-marketing infrastructures that deliver value and convenience for customers in an effort to keep them engaged and loyal to the brand. And for categories such as diapers, where parents can end up spending a few thousand dollars over several years, such relationship building is especially key.

"What makes mobile work is the recognition that the consumer is in charge," said Bryon Morrison, president of Omnicom's mobile agency, Ipsh, which recently handled the Pull-Ups effort for Kimberly-Clark. "This program allows moms to engage with multiple mobile channels and online ... and then builds the relationship by continuously optimizing the program and adding more value for each interaction."

But driving loyalty is more about delivering value beyond price, and most mobile customer-relationship-management programs still focus too much on coupons and SMS alerts about new products. Done correctly, CRM programs spur purchases without compromising price points, and can often reinforce pricing, because the brand is selling benefits and personalization.

"Coupons are almost exactly the opposite of CRM -- [coupons are] not used to drive repeat purchase over time, they're designed to spur trial among non-users and to promote usually new-product introductions based on price," said Eric Bader, managing partner of mobile-marketing firm Brand in Hand, Procter & Gamble's mobile agency of record.

Read more at: http://bit.ly/434h2I

Social Media – Is It A Fad?

August 14, 2009: summarized from Huffington Post -- Erik Qualman has been doing his homework on the social media phenomenon that has been spreading faster than (insert your own tasteless swine flu metaphor here).

His new book called Socialnomics comes out later this month. I think you'll be hearing a lot about it in the days to come because there is no hotter topic in business today than how to leverage social media to build communities around brands and then leverage them into revenue. The thinking is that as we build out our online personas -- migrate toward certain online groups centered around our interests, our likes, dislikes, opinions and friends -- products and services will find their way to us rather than we having to go out to find them. It changes the entire nature of advertising and how companies strive to create brand awareness and loyalty. When word of mouth and peer endorsements become the primary means by which products are sold, making a better product and having a sterling reputation becomes the absolute king of all currencies. Business school teaches us that good will is hard to quantify but having it in spades among your target market has never been more important.

The realization that a competitor who is socially networked better than you will eat your lunch has started a stampede of businesses and brands that are jumping on the social media bandwagon even faster than individual users were adopting Facebook last year -- when 100 million users joined in just 9 months, according to Qualman's statistics. He points out that 34% of bloggers (and there are over 200,000,000 blogs) post opinions about products and brands.

When you start to contemplate the impact of the statistics he cites and sources in his book you begin to understand the rapid shift in how business is seeing and reacting to the social media cascade. Erik discusses how two of the best marketers of the 20th century were Dale Carnegie and David Ogilvy. He says that today's consumers want to be related to "more in the Carnegie way." They want to be listened to and engaged in a dialog and not just hyped at. It no longer matters what you say about yourself. In fact, Qualman highlights that only 14% of people trust advertisers yet 78% of consumers trust peer recommendations. What matters is what others say about you.

Another interesting point Qualman makes is how Internet search is evolving to the extent that Google does not see its competition as Bing or Ask but rather Twitter and Facebook. I experienced this personally just the other day when my company's website went down. Our head of technology told me it was due to our DNS host having an outage. I knew if that were the case there would be a number of other companies experiencing the same thing. I Googled their name and came up empty handed. I then typed in a Twitter search and it came back with several tweets by other users complaining about the same issue and asking if others were experiencing the problem. Instantly, I was connected with kindred spirits with whom if nothing else, we could gripe to each other until the service was restored. In this case, the company missed the opportunity to monitor Twitter for their brand name. Had they been paying attention they could have been alerted to the issue quicker and they could have directly responded to those of us whose business was disrupted by the outage to reassure us it was being handled.

Qualman offers that today, 80% of companies now use LinkedIn (a social network dedicated to business networking) as a primary tool to find new talent. It's getting to the point you can't even compete to get a job if you're not versed in the ins and outs of social networking. That doesn't seem to be a problem for most. The fastest growing demographic on Facebook is females aged 55 to 65. That's probably because most other demographics just don't have that much more growth in them. With their recently updated figure of 250 million users, if Facebook were a country it would be the forth largest in the world (another statistical gem from Qualman's book).

Others are more skeptical of social media's ability to sell products and it must be said that there's a difference between social media advertising and building real communities around your brand. Many companies have been successful at generating a little buzz around their product for a short time by offering special Twitter promotions and giving away prizes to Twitter users who use their brand in tweets. But it's companies like Coca-Cola, who have built a Facebook community with over 3.5 million members (compared to Pepsi's paltry-by-comparison 226,000 member community) who are playing the game to win.

Read more at: http://bit.ly/SzldE

Twitter Forcing a Strategy Switch for Businesses

LM Comment: Some great examples social media at work in the real world.

August 16, 2009: summarized from Chicago Tribune -- Brand power takes on a whole new meaning on Twitter, where more than a million people follow Sockington, a tweeting feline who muses about litter boxes and salmon.
Companies would like to emulate that kind of success without drawing catcalls.

So far, however, the majority are still on the sidelines, and even most of those that have jumped in are social media newcomers, stepping up their presence in recent months as it became evident Twitter wasn't a quickly fading fad. Facebook, another social site, has let companies create their own pages only for the past two years.

What corporate marketers are discovering is that many of the strategies they've used for decades don't apply in the new social realm. For one thing, the companies have had to learn to let go of control. They can't be unnerved by an audience that talks back, often with brutal candor.

Such dialogue is occurring anyway, said market researcher Josh Bernoff.

"You can ignore it or you can try to fix it," said Bernoff, co-author of "Groundswell: Winning in a World Transformed by Social Technologies."

Microblogging site Twitter attracted 21.2 million U.S. visitors in July, according to Internet research firm ComScore Inc., up from 783,000 visitors a year earlier. Facebook's U.S. traffic more than doubled, to 87.7 million visitors, over the same 12-month period.

Yet only 26 percent of companies use social media such as Twitter and Facebook for corporate purposes, although 70 percent plan to jump in, according to a new survey by Minneapolis-based communications firm Russell Herder and Ethos Business Law.

But they should do so with caution, counsels Jeffrey Kalmikoff of Chicago-based hipster T-shirt company Threadless, which is a social media hit. This form of media is so new that it is difficult to predict with certainty what will succeed or bomb embarrassingly.

"Nobody has any idea of what they're doing on social media," said Kalmikoff, the company's chief creative officer. "It's just how comfortable your company is in taking risk. Some things can pay off; some things can fall flat."

Candymaker Mars Inc. saw both with its "Interweb the Rainbow" Skittles promotion. Its Twitter account initially was bombarded with off-color tweets. But the online campaign also has drawn more than 1 million fans to Skittles' Facebook page, where they are trading thoughts on everything from Skittles-infused vodka to whether the tart candies are tastier than M&Ms.

Threadless, which attracted more than 1 million buyers and designers for its T-shirts without any mainstream advertising, finds the best way to reach consumers is through its weekly e-mail newsletter. Facebook is also effective as a communications tool because it has detailed knowledge of its fan base. Twitter is tougher to gauge because it provides little read on who the company's followers are or whether they are even paying attention.

"Twitter is still a giant question mark," said Kalmikoff. "I'm highly suspicious of anyone who says they know how to use Twitter properly in a business setting."

Still, Threadless is experimenting with Twitter, using the site as both a bullhorn to blast messages to its nearly 1 million followers and as a means of commerce. The company currently is marketing "Tweets on Tees," shirts emblazoned with sayings like, "Life would be easier if you could mark people as spam."

But there's little doubt of Twitter's clout to influence public awareness, as JetBlue Airways demonstrated with its rollout last week of the "All-You-Can Jet" monthly pass for $599.

As the promotion became a "trending topic" on Twitter soon after it was announced Wednesday, JetBlue started to see multiple mentions of itself on the site every second. Most were consumers sharing word of the offer, although many peppered JetBlue's Twitter account with questions about how the deal worked.

"We were completely bombarded," said Lindsey Petersen, who works for JetBlue's frequent-flier program in Salt Lake City and is a member of the team that helps manage its Twitter account.

JetBlue planned to make the monthly pass available through Aug. 21. But after less than 36 hours, officials were worried about having to curtail the promotion because the carrier was running out of seats. The airline has only 65,000 airplane seats to sell each day.

"We're going to learn a lot from this," said Jenny Dervin, spokeswoman for the New York-based carrier. "Next time we do this, we may have different rules around it. But, honestly, Twitter will tell us. It's the ultimate market research tool."

To connect with consumers on these new media and to remain timely, companies have to cede absolute control of an advertising message, a risky proposition.

While about five officials at Southwest Airlines typically vet every press release for accuracy and nuance, communications staffer Christi Day flies solo on Twitter. She acts as the discount carrier's voice without editing from her bosses.

"It is a little scary," Day said of the challenge of remaining on point while trying to reflect the humor and playfulness that the carrier encourages in its employees.

JetBlue and Southwest have the largest presence among airlines on Twitter, with about 1 million and 460,000 followers, respectively. Both carriers share a steady stream of information, from flight delays to deals.

Day also has started providing live tweets from the company's news conferences as well as updates of weather-related problems and service issues. This summer she tweeted about a hole in the fuselage of one jet, for example, that forced an emergency landing in Charleston, W.Va.

"That's what people are hungry for: providing the facts," Day said. She added that "having that direct communication with our customers allows us to squash any rumors that may be going on."

After spending decades perfecting slogans and one-way conversations, companies that tap social media have to be prepared for an open dialogue with consumers, whose responses can be blunt.

American Airlines is experimenting with a Faceback application in development that lets families and far-flung friends plan trips together. So far, 21 reviewers have rated it an average of 2.5 stars out of a possible 5, and the airline is using the feedback to improve the planning tool.

"To create a great product, you've got to test it out with loyal customers that will be blunt: 'I like this, I don't like that,' " said Billy Sanez, an American spokesman. "It's like a virtual focus group and an active user group that's testing it out."

American prefers Facebook to Twitter.

"Twitter is more of a mass simple-messaging platform," Sanez said. "Facebook is a more robust conversation. You can get to know the consumer a lot better."

Its Facebook offerings include a page called Travel Bag devoted to trip planning, as well as content from its inflight magazine. The wall also features plenty of customer comments, pro and con, along with flight photos.

United Airlines and struggling country musician Dave Carroll learned the power of these new tools after Carroll gained Internet fame in July with a song tweaking the carrier for breaking his guitar, then refusing to pay for the damage. He and friends used Facebook and Twitter to get the word out.

Although its brand is known worldwide, United had a difficult time countering the firestorm of publicity because it was new to social media, Bernoff said. "You don't have a lot of defenses because you don't have a lot of followers."

In contrast, Carroll got a huge career boost. His YouTube video has been viewed 4.9 million times, and he plans to release a follow-up Tuesday. Carroll said he's hired three people just to handle the crush of publicity and new bookings.

Read more at: http://bit.ly/10iAvu

Mobile Leaders Recoil From The Spam Trap

LM Comment: Some good background on the SPAM and mobile marketing.

August 17, 2009: summarized from DM News -- Because mobile phones continue to evolve and consumer adoption is still growing, mobile compliance can be a tricky area. While mobile spam is not new, the definition of what is and is not mobile spam is still being studied by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), the Mobile Marketing Association (MMA), Forrester Research and the Wireless Association (CTIA).

Mobile spam can be divided into two general categories: legitimate marketers not following best practices and sending unsolicited messages, and the more devious malware attacks, in which malicious messages are sent through text or e-mail to attack a phone's operating system. Either way, this spam is annoying to consumers.

"On the mobile device, people have a lower tolerance for spam than they do anywhere else, and they often have to pay for messages," says Mike Wehrs, president and CEO of the MMA.

Contributing to this intolerance is the fact that consumers often will stop what they are doing to read a new mobile message. "When the phone beeps, they go to see what it is, so marketers should be very careful that they are sending targeted messages so as not to disturb the consumer," Wehrs explains.

To help legitimate marketers become compliant in the mobile marketing space and to help define what is appropriate as the landscape changes, the MMA and Forrester have issued a number of best practices, most of which push for marketer transparency and consumer control.

"Marketers should enable the end user to control the communications that are received at the device, and enable them as a user, not through the carrier or customer service, to say, 'I don't want any messages from short codes' and also to create lists of who can get through," says Daniel Hoffman, SVP of communications at SMobile Systems.

One provider offering this particular option is AT&T. Customers can restrict the sources of e-mail that reach their phone at mymessages.wireless.att.com, or reply to unwanted e-mail messages with "BLOCK" in the body of the response. AT&T users also can stop unwanted short code messages by replying "STOP" in the body of the response to prevent future messages from that short code or by blocking numbers at att.com/smartlimitsforwireless.

In addition, the MMA lets consumers report spam on its site.

Legally speaking, mobile marketers are required to follow the CAN-SPAM Act, meaning that consumers must opt in to receive marketing messages.

The opt-in guidelines are much stricter for mobile than e-mail, however, because of both costs and the personal nature of the phone. For example, if a consumer signs up to receive mobile messaging from a retailer for a deal on jeans, that marketer can only text them about jeans. A consumer has to opt in separately to receive messaging about sweaters.

According to the MMA, a consumer should be able to opt out of a message even after opting in. There should be a clear way to do so in every mobile marketing message. In addition, a consumer should know what kind of personal information is being stored and how it is being stored.

While the idea is to be more transparent with the consumer, sometimes letting consumers know what data you're tracking can create a sticky situation, since more targeted and relevant mobile messages require more personal information on the consumer.

"As you eliminate the ability to do targeting what you are doing is making it closer to spam," Wehrs adds. "So, there is a delicate balance to being targeted and relevant without going too far and making the user feel that their privacy is being invaded."

The CTIA is currently working with the MMA to put together its own list of wireless best practices, which are expected to be released at the end of the year.

"We are trying to figure out how the carrier community can facilitate responsible advertising to consumers while at the same time protecting the privacy of the subscriber base," says David Diggs, VP of wireless Internet development for CTIA.

Read more at: http://bit.ly/8DZRR

Tuesday, August 11, 2009

Internet Marketing and Social Media

August 4, 2009: summarized from Direct News -- The link between internet marketing and social media such as Facebook has grown by 46 per cent in the last two years, new research suggests.

According to a study from the Association of National Advertisers (ANA), which was produced in conjunction with BtoB Magazine and marketing services group mktg, 66 per cent of marketers have utilised sites such as Facebook in 2009.

It was also discovered that 50 per cent of firms employ viral videos, which represented a 25 per cent increase on 2007's findings.

Bob Liodice, president and chief executive officer of the ANA, said: "As more media platforms become available, it is imperative that all marketers continue to assess their capabilities and select the platforms that are best suited to help them."

Earlier this week, Email Data Source reported that there has been a "dramatic" increase in the number of email marketing campaigns using Facebook and microblogging website Twitter as linked-to portals.

More at: http://tinyurl.com/latypn

QR Codes In U.S. Are Finally Starting To Catch On

LM Comment: Interesting technology, definitely worth keeping an eye on.

July 28, 2009: summarized from Advertising Age -- As anyone who has ever struggled to manually input a URL into a mobile phone browser will tell you, there are relatively few joys to be had in the physical act of "texting."

Sure Apple, Palm, Google and BlackBerry have made great strides in providing elegant, easier-to-use keypads on their latest mobile devices. But there more than 4.1 billion mobile devices in the world today and most of them are your standard, garden-variety handset with a small screens and numeric keypads.

Inputting long lines of text on such devices, even with normal-size fingers, is a clumsy experience at best that can leave even the deftest "text-er" feeling ham-handed. This poses a huge barrier to mobile internet service adoption and, of course, marketing.

Surprising, then, that the QR code -- sometimes dubbed the URL killer -- has yet to catch-on outside of Asia. Until now that is. A flurry of new QR code activity from cultural tastemakers and media platforms alike may finally push the barcode into the mainstream.

For those unfamiliar, QR codes are 2D bar codes that contain small bits of data, such as URL strings, phone numbers and e-mail addresses. To read the QR code, a user simply launches a "reader" on their mobile device and takes a snapshot of the image. The software will then trigger the appropriate response, which can include launching a URL in the phone's browser to streaming a video or MP3.

Long popular in Japan, where QR codes are used on everything from bananas to advertising to tombstones, the following developments may prove the tipping point for the technology worldwide:

"9": QR codes will play heavily into this fall's promotion of the Tim Burton-produced film "9." Consumers who have QR readers on their mobile devices will be able to scan the code for exclusive clips from the movie and commentary from the director. Focus Features debuted the campaign this past weekend at ComicCon in San Diego.

Green Day: For the band's new album, "21st Century Breakdown," Green Day employed QR codes in magazine ads, posters, stickers and more. The QR code directs users to a special mobile site that enables the downloading of exclusive images and videos. The group partnered with Delivr to provide the content and media.

YouTube: The largest video platform in the world began to embrace QR codes this year. If you access the mobile YouTube site through an iPhone or Android device, you will now have the option to generate a QR code that embeds a link to the video.

Firefox: Similarly, Mozilla's recently began to offer an add-on for its Firefox browser called Mobile Barcoder. The extension allows Firefox users to users to simply generate a 2D QR code of either a URL or selection of text for easy transfer to a mobile device.

Luis Vuitton and Takashi Murakami, Marc Jacobs: Japan still sets the bar for radical evolutions of the QR code. Tokyo-based creative agency SET is bringing a design sensibility to something that -- for the moment -- has been a geeky-aesthetic. The agency brought together Louis Vuitton and Takashi Murakami for a unique spin on the QR codes. And for Marc Jacobs, the QR code gets a decidedly artful hand-drawn rendering.

Of course there have been some early, but decidedly mixed, experiments with QR codes outside of Japan. Most notably, Citysearch ran a pilot program in San Francisco last year allowing users to get restaurant reviews from stickers placed in the windows of participating establishments. And advertisers like Pepsi, Siemens and Volvo have all run QR campaigns in the past few months.

But it's only more recently, with the rise of the iPhone and Google's Android, that QR codes are starting to see a rise in Europe and the U.S. Both of those devices, with simple-to-install QR apps, allow users to bypass handset/carrier relationships that previously stalled adoption, to download and use the readers of their choice.

And as consumers get more familiar with scanning the codes, the future for QR codes will only get brighter. PSFK recently reported that scientists in Australia have developed a color barcode called Mobile Multi-Colour Composite 2D-Barcode that can hold more complex data and entire images and videos, sans URL. Even better, the new codes will work with a mobile device whether or not an Internet connection is actually available -- which means nearly instant, immersive experiences.

Given that, it's not hard to imagine a not-too-distant future where QR codes will become the primary bridge connecting real and virtual worlds.

Imagine a QR code becoming the call-to-action on every print ad or billboard. We'll watch movie trailers while waiting for the bus and stream hit singles upon passing by a poster. Beyond that, QR codes will become affixed to every conceivable product in a retail environment. Imagine using QR codes on your next trip to the grocery store to view recipes, learn about the farmer who grew your lettuce and even snag a coupon -- it's already happening in Japan, now its time for the rest of the world to catch-up.

More at: http://tinyurl.com/npgtrt

Research Report: The Audience for Online Video-Sharing Sites Shoots Up

LM Comment: Definitely a trend worth monitoring.

July 2009: from Pew Internet & American Life Project -- As the audience for online video continues to grow, a leading edge of internet users are migrating their viewing from their computer screens to their TV screens.

Young adults continue to lead the adoption curve in online video viewing. Nine in ten internet users ages 18-29 use video sharing sites, up from 72% one year ago. On a typical day in 2009, 36% of young adult internet users watched video on these sites, compared with just 30% in 2008.

Online adults ages 30-49 also showed big gains over the past year; 67% now use video sharing sites, up from 57% in 2008.

Online video viewing is still far from being the norm among internet users ages 50 and older, however, this segment of the internet audience continues to grow each year. Among internet users ages 50-64, 41% now say they watch video on sites like YouTube, which is up from 34% in 2008. Likewise, 27% of wired seniors ages 65 and older now access video on these sites, compared with just 19% who were doing so at this time last year.

The Audience for Online Video Sharing Sites Shoots Up